Brit Prog
FACT 10’s “The Twenty Best…” column gave Andy Votel the opportunity to focus on Prog Rock. His breakout was awe-inspiring, adopting as it did an almost unfettered globalist approach to the genre. Offerings from Sweden, Yugoslavia, Wales, Greece, Korea, Turkey and Australia rubbed shoulders. The subsequently released, Votel-curated Prog is Not a Four Letter Word collection on Delay 68, was my favourite compilation of last year, an unmissable romp.
However, I confess I took issue with Votel’s thesis. His argument, albeit one made in the face of what he perceives to be hipster disdain, was that the exotic bounty of Global Prog made irrelevant the vile excess and cultural tepidity of Brit Prog. Remaining suspicious of Prog, it seems we’ve yet to overthrow Punk’s depressing orthodoxy. I’d relish a world when these ten fabulous Brit Prog records cropped up as regularly as Never Mind The Bollocks or London Calling in people’s favourites.


Votel approaches the genre from the perspective of the Hip-Hop break-hunter, which method though, it yields great music in the terrains of Library and Soundtrack music, fails to do justice to the knotty arrhythmia of the best Prog. A record like The Egg’s Civil Service might tick the appropriate boxes, Votel himself singling their eponymous debut for praise amidst foreign offerings, but Van Der Graaf Generator’s quite awesome Pawn Hearts, the quintessential “difficult” UK Prog LP by merit of its preposterous cracked brooding soundscapes won’t gain acceptance.


Furthermore much of the music on Prog Is Not a Four Letter Word in the strictest terms isn’t Prog, but Psych. It’s a difficult to distinction to make, but Prog makes an unpeggable leap into the future, while Psych builds on the whimsical, cosmic, LSD-addled legacy of 60s Psychedelia. So Henry Cow are Prog and Gong are Psych. A record as self-consciously curious as Quiet Sun’s Mainstream by the pre-This Heat Charles Hayward is clearly Prog, but Family’s exquisite Music In a Doll’s House, even though it forms some strange shapes of its own and cleaves to a theme, by merit of Roger Chapman’s bluesy vocals, might just be a Psych record.


Votel rightfully discharges Genesis and Yes without the slightest consideration for some reason Caravan get caught in the friendly fire. Perhaps a victim of the “breaks” aesthetic which dictates that all offerings must be obscure, otherwise they’d not be respectable Akai fodder? But I wonder how many people have actually heard Caravan’s In the Land of Grey and Pink, a really splendid record? If it’s Canterbury records you’re interested in, Kevin Ayers’ Whatevershebringswesing is worth investigating, the drum breaks on which in fact might even find favour with Hip-Hop producers.


Prog’s calling card might be its strangeness. Comus’s First Utterance and The Third Ear Band’s Alchemy represent some kind of benchmark for the weird. Both records are talismans for both the Avant-Folk movement and latterly the oeuvre of Current 93 and Nurse with Wound. This is a folk music so true to folk music’s spirit of blasphemy and the unheimlich that they sidestep the clichés which bedevil even the best of it.


If there’s one thing which people, even the “fat, boring, smelly and socially inept” Prog fans who Votel mercilessly parodies in his piece, won’t tell you about is how majestically beautiful and blissful some of this music can be. I’d always assumed all King Crimson would be somehow violent, brutish and ugly. Theorist Mark Fisher once nicely caricatured what was so off-putting about Prog thus: “that jabbing masculine jerkiness, that anti-plateau jumpiness”, but strange to tell Court of The Crimson King is at once gentle and awe-inspiringly gorgeous. Curved Air’s Second Album is another example of sheer loveliness in Prog.
With all sense of the possible imminence of a new revolution in music ebbing away, the attraction of Prog is that it represents a sense of an underlying tradition in opposition (rather than, like Punk, a false sense of revolt through rupture). Votel’s excellent compilation represents a nascent interest in this music. With some of today’s brightest lights revealing an empathy with Prog’s overwrought involuted textures, the Black Prog-lite of Sa-Ra, the Disco-Prog of Jackson and Delia and Gavin and the Sampladelic-Library Prog of the Ghost Box label, then perhaps it’s about time to confront it on its own terms? Global Prog is one thing, but whether it was France’s Heldon or Italy’s Banco del Mutuo Soccorso, in fact almost everywhere with the exception of Germany’s Krautrock scene, back in the day all eyes were on the UK.
Originally published in FACT magazine.




